Home Blog Multiple offers

Two offers. Take the higher one? Here's what I check before the price.

By Trevor Barber, Realtor · November 19, 2026 · 6 min read

Watch the 3 things I check before the price

Short answer: Not always. Price is just one part of an offer. Before you pick one, look at how the buyer is paying, what they're asking for, and how likely the price is to appraise. The best offer is the one that actually makes it to the closing table.

Getting more than one offer on your home feels great. Then you have to choose, and the bigger number is staring right at you. It's easy to grab it and move on.

But a higher price that falls apart in three weeks, or one that comes with a long list of requests, can leave you with less money and more stress than a lower, cleaner offer. Here's how I help sellers compare offers so you keep more of what you've built.

Key takeaways

  • The highest offer isn't automatically the best one. Look at the whole offer, not just the price.
  • Check three things: how the buyer is paying, what they're asking for, and how likely the price is to appraise.
  • A low appraisal is a risk you can see coming. Knowing the recent sales and where the market is heading lets you plan for it before it sends you back to the negotiating table.
  • Compare offers by what you'd actually walk away with after the buyer's requests, not by the price on page one.
  • Bidding wars are less common right now. In October 2026, homes listed received an average of 2.0 offers and only 11% sold above list price, according to NAR.
  • Sometimes the lower offer puts more money in your pocket and is more likely to close.

Should I always take the highest offer on my house?

No. The highest offer is only the best one if it's also likely to close and leaves you with the most money once the buyer's requests are subtracted.

An offer is a package. It includes the price, but also how the buyer will pay, how much earnest money they're putting down, what they want from you, when they want to close, and what the contract says about the inspection and the appraisal. Two offers can look $10,000 apart on price and end up much closer, or flipped, once you add all of that up.

How do I compare multiple offers on my house?

Compare them on the same three questions, then compare what each one would actually put in your pocket. Here are the three things I look at before the price.

1. How is the buyer paying?

Find out whether it's cash or a loan, what kind of loan, and how much the lender has actually verified. That tells you how likely the buyer is to make it to closing.

A cash buyer has no loan approval to wait on, so there are fewer places for the deal to stall. A buyer with a loan can be just as strong if the lender has already checked their income, assets and credit. A pre-approval usually means the lender did that work. A pre-qualification usually means the lender gave a quick estimate based on what the buyer told them. When I'm comparing offers for a seller, I want to know which one I'm looking at.

2. What is the buyer asking for?

Look at every request that costs you money or time: seller-paid closing costs, repair credits, a long timeline to close, or a closing date that doesn't fit your next move.

These requests come straight out of your proceeds, so they matter as much as the price. Here's a simple example with made-up numbers:

Table: Two offers, side by side (example only)

Offer AOffer B
Offer price$400,000$390,000
Seller-paid closing costs requested$10,000$0
Repair credit requested$5,000$0
Price after requests$385,000$390,000

Takeaway: the offer that's $10,000 higher on paper leaves this seller $5,000 less before any other costs. These are example numbers, not a real sale. Your mortgage payoff and other closing costs come out of both offers the same way, which is why I always walk through your full net with you before you choose.

3. How likely is a low appraisal?

Know the risk before you pick an offer. If the buyer is getting a loan, the lender won't lend more than the home appraises for, so you want to know how likely each price is to appraise. That comes from the data: what comparable homes nearby actually sold for, and which way the market is moving.

An offer that lines up with recent sales is low risk. An offer well above anything nearby has sold for is higher risk, especially in a cooling market where the latest sales may come in lower than the ones from a few months ago. That doesn't mean you turn the higher offer down. It means you see the risk coming and plan for it.

Most of that risk can be managed up front. Pricing your home from real sold data keeps offers close to what the market supports, and knowing the risk early lets us plan for it before it becomes a problem. Handled that way, the appraisal is far less likely to send you back to the negotiating table. If it still comes in low, the price goes back to negotiation, the appraiser can be asked to review sales they missed, and depending on the contract, the buyer may be able to walk away. The goal is to avoid getting there.

Is the market still producing multiple offers?

Less than it was. Nationally, homes are getting about two offers on average, and far fewer are selling above list price than a year ago.

Table: How competitive the market was in October 2026 (U.S.)

MeasureOctober 2026A year earlier
Average offers per listed home2.02.1
Homes sold above list price11%19%
Cash sales29%29%
Median time on market (days)3534
Months of supply5.14.4
Contracts terminated (last 3 months)7%7%

Takeaway: with fewer bidding wars, picking the offer that will actually close matters more than squeezing out the top dollar. Source: National Association of Realtors, October 2026 Realtors Confidence Index and existing-home sales report (released November 12, 2026). These are national numbers, because these reports don't break offer counts out by county.

Closer to home, the Nashville area has more homes coming on the market. Redfin reported Nashville new listings up 22.1% from a year earlier in the four weeks ending October 11, 2026, the biggest year-over-year increase among the 50 most populous U.S. metros Redfin tracks. More choices for buyers means each offer you get deserves a careful look.

Can a lower offer really put more money in my pocket?

Yes. Once you subtract what each buyer is asking for, a lower offer with fewer requests can leave you with more, and it's often the one more likely to close.

Think about what a failed deal costs. If a contract falls apart, your home goes back on the market, buyers wonder what went wrong, and the clock starts over while you keep paying the mortgage, taxes and utilities. In NAR's October 2026 survey, 7% of contracts were terminated in the prior three months, and 14% had a delayed closing in the past three months. A clean offer from a well-qualified buyer cuts down on those risks.

How I help you choose the right offer

Before we list, I build your price from homes that actually sold near you, not wishful thinking. That's the best way to keep the appraisal from becoming a surprise later.

When offers come in, I lay them out side by side for you: price, how each buyer is paying, what the lender has verified, what they're asking for, and the timeline. Then I walk you through what each one would leave you after your payoff and closing costs. You make the call with the full picture in front of you, and I negotiate firmly through inspection and closing so the offer you pick makes it to the closing table.

If you're thinking about selling in Hendersonville, Gallatin, White House or anywhere in Sumner County, that work starts long before the first offer shows up. My posts on what to fix before you sell and what buyers notice first are good places to start.

Sources

  1. National Association of Realtors, Realtors Confidence Index, October 2026 (released November 12, 2026).
  2. National Association of Realtors, "Existing-Home Sales Decreased 5.5% in October, According to NAR Report" (October 2026 data; released November 12, 2026).
  3. Redfin, "Sellers' Asking Prices Fall For the First Time Since March" (four weeks ending October 11, 2026; published October 15, 2026, updated October 21, 2026).

Frequently asked questions

Should I always accept the highest offer on my house?

No. The highest offer is only the best one if it's also likely to close and leaves you with the most money after the buyer's requests. Compare how each buyer is paying, what they're asking for and how the price lines up with recent sales before you decide.

Is a cash offer better than an offer with a loan?

A cash offer usually has fewer steps that can go wrong, because there's no loan approval to wait on. That doesn't make it automatically better. A strong, fully approved loan offer at a higher price can still come out ahead, so compare what each one leaves you after the buyer's requests.

What's the difference between pre-qualified and pre-approved?

Pre-qualified usually means a lender gave a quick estimate based on what the buyer told them. Pre-approved usually means the lender actually checked income, assets and credit. When you're comparing offers, the more the lender has verified, the more confident you can be that the buyer can close.

How do I know if an offer will appraise?

Compare the offer price to what similar homes nearby actually sold for and to where the market is heading. An offer in line with recent sales is low risk, and one well above them is higher risk. Pricing from real sold data and knowing that risk before you accept an offer helps keep the deal from going back to the negotiating table.

What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than the offer price?

The buyer's lender won't lend more than the home appraised for, so the price usually goes back to the negotiating table. If the appraiser missed recent nearby sales, the appraiser can be asked to review them. Depending on the contract, the buyer may also be able to walk away, which is why it pays to see a low appraisal coming before you accept an offer.

How many offers are homes getting right now?

In NAR's October 2026 Realtors Confidence Index, homes listed received an average of 2.0 offers, down from 2.2 in September. Only 11% of homes sold above list price, the lowest share since NAR began tracking it in April 2021. With fewer bidding wars, choosing the offer that will actually close matters more.

Want to see where you stand before the offers come in?

Take a quick, free quiz that scores how ready you are to sell and breaks down exactly where you stand. It takes about three minutes.

Get my free readiness score Book a free 30-minute call
Trevor Barber

Trevor Barber is a Realtor and Affiliate Broker with Benchmark Realty, LLC, based in White House, TN. With 68 homes sold and a 5.0 rating on Google, he helps families buy, sell, downsize and move up across Sumner County and Middle Tennessee. More about Trevor

Keep reading: See how I sell your home · Buy first or sell first? · Fix up or sell as-is? · Fix Up or Sell As-Is? How to Decide Which Repairs Pay · What Buyers Notice First When You Sell Your Home